We’re virtually three weeks into Starfleet Academy, and the present, with some often rebellious rockiness, has began to search out its area of interest on this planet of Star Trek. But one factor has stored bothering me throughout its first three episodes.
I do not know when this present is going down.
Now, I do know this can be a silly factor to be eager about. At the top of the day, it doesn’t really matter to Starfleet Academy to know the place precisely it matches within the Star Trek timeline. We understand it’s the thirty second century; we all know approximate timing—it’s someplace across the early 3190s—and we additionally know that, actually, nothing has occurred within the present but that rooting it in a single very particular time and place has required a precise rationalization on-screen. Especially so contemplating that the one Trek present Starfleet Academy has to have a direct reference to on the timeline is Discovery, a sequence that’s not an ongoing concern.
I assume a part of it’s I’m a little bit of an oldhead, particularly on the subject of Starfleet Academy‘s rambunctiously charming cast of kids. The Trek I grew up with, namely Deep Space Nine and Voyager, opened by rooting itself in relation to direct moments in the late-24th-century setting they shared, spinning out of TNG—the personal fallout Picard’s assimilation has on Ben Sisko and the outbreak of battle in earnest between the Maquis and the Cardassian Union. But whereas Academy does give us a number of hints in regards to the passage of time in what we’ve seen thus far (Darem’s message to his mother and father on the prime of episode three, “Vitus Reflux,” notes that three weeks have handed since lessons started, for instance), it’s broadly very obscure about it.
Again, that’s not stopped one tiny nook of my Trek mind from relentlessly obsessing over it, irrespective of how little it issues. So let me try to lay down all of the information we all know and attempt to lay out a working concept.
Star Trek: Discovery‘s Timeline in Comparison to Starfleet Academy
© Paramount
Discovery‘s third, fourth, and fifth seasons give us a broad timeframe for its personal occasions. Michael Burnham efficiently jumps from the twenty third century to the thirty second within the opening of season three within the 12 months 3188—and shortly thereafter (for us not less than), because of temporal displacement, the USS Discovery and her crew comply with in 3189. In that point, they study in regards to the cataclysmic galaxy-wide ramifications of the occasion often known as the Burn and resolve its mysterious origins, laying the groundwork for a largely shattered Federation to begin rebuilding itself.
Likewise, the following two seasons are given stardates that place them within the following years: 3190 for season 4 and 3191 for season 5. Which means we are able to date some vital issues for the setup of Starfleet Academy‘s own internal timeline: Discovery season four opens with the formal reopening of Starfleet Academy itself, with Michael giving a speech to mark the occasion in the premiere episode, “Kobayashi Maru,” and the season climaxes in “Coming Home” with the revelation that Starfleet and United Earth have begun talks for the latter to rejoin the Federation.
Starfleet Academy‘s Timeline in Comparison to Star Trek: Discovery
© Paramount
It’s the brand new present itself that begins throwing a number of timeline curveballs. The first episode, “Kids These Days”, has to comply with a while after the occasions of Discovery season 4, as a result of its entire premise is in regards to the USS Athena making its option to Earth to start lessons, the primary educational 12 months for the establishment to happen on the planet since Starfleet was ousted after the Burn over a century prior (these lessons are, particularly, described as the autumn semester, so no matter 12 months it’s going down in, it’s later in it). The Athena additionally has no points with a prolonged warp journey from the place it was bringing aboard its final college students and Earth itself, so the decision of the dilithium shortages uncovered by Discovery on the finish of season 4 has recovered sufficient that it’s not less than not misplaced for the Athena to casually be utilizing its warp drive.
But when the ship is attacked by Nus Braka and the Venari Ral, we get our first odd observe: the Discovery can’t come to the Athena‘s aid as it’s at the moment within the midst of an in depth refit. In Star Trek, the time period “refit” is normally solely used to explain a starship present process intensive technological overhauls, both full system updates and even its outdated self being changed by a brand new class of ship—transferring the title within the course of however noting that refit with an alphabetical letter hooked up to its NCC registry quantity (all of the variations of Enterprise, the Voyager-A in Prodigy, and naturally, the Discovery itself).
We solely ever see the Discovery bear two main refits on-screen: the three-week course of taken to replace its methods and know-how from the twenty third century to thirty second century requirements, changing into the Discovery-A within the course of, within the season three episode “Scavengers,” which takes place shortly after the Discovery has emerged out of time in 3189, after which once more within the season 5 finale, “Life Itself,” in an epilogue set many years after the occasions of the present.
This can’t be the identical refit talked about in “Kids These Days,” as a result of all that occurs earlier than the decision of the Burn and United Earth rejoining the Federation. Considering as that, even delayed by the Venari Ral assault, we’re advised that it’s going to take the Athena round 15 hours to get to Earth, we are able to safely assume {that a} good chunk of Discovery season three after its refit didn’t occur within the house of lower than a day!
Our subsequent actual piece of timeline data comes first in episode two of Starfleet Academy, “Beta Test,” the place it’s established that the Federation continues to be within the technique of deciding the place its new official headquarters can be, after being positioned on the USS Federation all through Discovery seasons three via 5 (it’s finally determined to be established on Betazed, somewhat than its pre-Burn house in Paris on Earth).
Then “Vitus Reflux,” three weeks after the occasions of “Kids These Days,” offers us one other: Jett Reno, speaking to Darem about his points along with his fellow cadet Genesis, notes that she “left a starship on the edge of creation” to remain in a relationship with the Academy’s cadet grasp and first officer, Lura Thok, and take a instructing place on the academy. That ship, after all, needs to be the Discovery, however contemplating that Reno is a frequently established member of the ship’s crew all through seasons 4 and 5 with no point out of her taking go away, that will imply that Starfleet Academy has to happen after the conclusion of Discovery‘s fifth season in, presumably, the fall of 3191.
Enter Tilly
© Paramount
That brings us to one other important factor bridging Discovery and Starfleet Academy together: Sylvia Tilly. Once the academy is re-established in Discovery‘s fourth season, Tilly is given an opportunity to teach its first new cadets, departing Discovery as a full-time member of the crew in the season four episode “All Is Possible”, which sees her go on a training mission with some of those early cadets. Tilly is seen again in season four’s finale after which extra frequently all through season 5, the place she mentions her work instructing academy cadets.
We know that, sooner or later, Tilly will make an look in Starfleet Academy—one that may seemingly be the factor that really does clear up when the present is ready. But if Starfleet Academy is in regards to the firstclass of scholars for the reason that Burn in round fall 3191, and Tilly has additionally been coaching cadets after the Academy was formally reopened initially of season 4 the 12 months prior, how will we reconcile that?
Well, via a technicality. Presumably earlier than both the development or retrofit of the USS Athena to grow to be the Academy’s new travelling house primarily based out of San Francisco, Starfleet had really been instructing its first academy cadets within the discipline, primarily based on the USS Federation and Starfleet HQ, because it was re-established in 3190. Once issues calm down once more by the conclusion of Discovery season 5 and extra member worlds have rejoined the Federation, or not less than begun to, Starfleet should have determined to reopen the academy on Earth, and thus Starfleet Academy follows the primary class of cadets to be skilled on the planet for the reason that Burn, as an alternative of the primary academy college students in any respect.
Is Any of This Actually Important to Starfleet Academy?
Absolutely not. If something, it’s higher for the present to not catch itself up making an attempt to over-explain issues and its connections to different Star Trek materials—in spite of everything, it’s serving as a significant new onboarding level for brand new followers, simply as Discovery did earlier than it. But typically it’s enjoyable to only nerd out over issues that don’t actually matter, so long as you don’t get too labored up over it.
Want extra io9 information? Check out when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on movie and TV, and every thing you could learn about the way forward for Doctor Who.
