Display Ad Cover-Image

Should You Mix Them On The Same Site?


You like cash, proper? Do you want cashing in a second time on web sites and content material you’ve already developed? I positive do, that’s why I designed a case research to find out whether or not it’s attainable to show a wholesome affiliate web site into a greater earner by monetizing it by show advertisements.

I get it, you’re instantly skeptical, proper?

Of course, you might be. Multiple earnings streams are all the time superior, however why would you ever monetize a web site in a manner that may get in the best way of the way it pays you now? Most affiliate entrepreneurs shun advertisements as a result of their websites become profitable by drawing individuals on to affiliate hyperlinks, not advertisements.

People on the affiliate facet rightfully ask: Won’t advertisements distract individuals away from the hyperlinks to my affiliate merchandise? Won’t I lose the dear belief of my readers? Will my web site load slower?

Those issues are precisely what I got down to take a look at on this newest case research.

In the next article, you’re going to study what impact the introduction of advertisements had on load time, visitors, earnings, and different web site development elements.

Finally, you’ll stroll away with a definitive reply on if show advertisements are a beneficial addition to your affiliate content material websites.

For those that choose video content material, right here’s a video abstract of what you’re about to learn beneath.

For people who like the small print, the numbers, and extra, stick with it…

First, a fast overview of what show advertisements are and the way they match into the affiliate mannequin.

What are Display Ads?

Though you doubtless filter out loads of show advertisements you see every single day, they’re far too frequent to disregard fully. Google Ads stays the most important advert platform serving the web and has solely gotten higher at delivering focused advertisements wherever you go.

You’ll see them on most websites. As an off-hand instance, right here’s one which’s been following me round.

Vegas Display Ad sample

Unless you aggressively block scripts with a software like Adblock, you’ve seen them, and you could have even been tempted to click on.

If you haven’t used show advertisements in your web site earlier than, the setup is fairly easy. You apply to an advert community, meet the {qualifications}, after which observe their customized directions on the way to arrange your web site to show their advertisements.

It’s laborious to be extra particular as a result of the {qualifications} will fluctuate from web site to web site. Most would require a minimal stage of visitors. AdThrive requires a minimal of 100,000 month-to-month web page views. Smaller networks like Mediavine require 25,000 classes a month.

They are more likely to have content material restrictions in relation to grownup subjects and imagery. As you’d count on, the perfect networks have demanding requirements.

If you continue to want extra background on show advertisements, this short guide can fill in some of the blanks.

Now that we’re all caught up, right here’s how my case research rolled out.

The Case Study

The research concerned a single affiliate web site. After some consideration,  I selected an internet site that was already reasonably profitable with affiliate provides (incomes roughly $8,000 per 30 days).

I had less-valuable websites to select from, however I selected this one as a result of I wished a web site that had an honest quantity of visitors.

Good visitors means sudden tendencies will stand out from the static. I wished to have statistically important conduct to investigate when the advertisements appeared.

traffic overview chart display on a tablet device

My plan was to position the advertisements throughout 37 informational content material items on the positioning.

I monetized the informational content material items with electronic mail opt-ins to rewards like ebooks. The ROI for an electronic mail handle is nowhere close to as beneficial as hyperlinks to affiliate merchandise that I positioned on different pages.

So even when the worst occurred.  Even if the advertisements that ate all of the clicks, turned away the readers, or destroyed my web site pace… it nonetheless would solely have an effect on these low ROI informational pages.

The concept that advertisements solely be served to sure pages generated some main resistance from advert networks (extra on that in only a bit), however I used to be capable of restrict advertisements to these pages ultimately by discovering the fitting advert associate.

Choosing the advert community for the experiment

Two networks got here extra extremely really helpful than the others: Ezoic and Media Vine. However, neither one was capable of assist with the experiment.

Both demanded that I permit advertisements on all pages or none of them. That wasn’t one thing I used to be keen to do, given the dangers acknowledged above.

I’ve had individuals come to me and say that each these networks permit pick-and-choose choices, however that’s not my expertise.

Actual dialog with Mediavine’s rep:


I actually wasn’t obsessed with putting in the sitewide code updates each platforms require. Once once more, I’m attempting to guard the positioning total, and a few advert platforms are identified to decelerate web sites.

Ultimately, I went with a smaller and extra versatile community known as Newor Media (invitation hyperlink). This one got here extremely really helpful by some pals who had longtime advert expertise.

Newor Media web page

Newor claimed that their platform doesn’t influence pace (we’ll cowl how that went within the information). They let me choose and select the pages that have been served by advertisements.

Ultimately, Newor was additionally the one platform of the three that was chill with being a part of an experiment.

Newor labored with me to find out how the advertisements would seem on the pages. That resulted within the web page format adjustments you’ll be able to see within the subsequent part.


How web page format modified

Layout 1: The Original

before placement ad

This is how the web page appears with out advertisements. It’s a format designed to serve informational content material. Just previous the primary part, my electronic mail inline opt-ins are distributed discreetly all through the web page. One was positioned simply previous the introduction, and one other each few hundred phrases.

There’s additionally an electronic mail opt-in on the sidebar, slightly additional down the web page. The inline opt-ins are simply written calls-to-action, whereas the sidebar includes a full cowl picture of the e-book that signups obtain.

The web page is constructed to serve electronic mail opt-ins. Before Newor positioned the advertisements, there’s nothing that distracted from that function.

Layout 2: After the Ads

after placement ad

This is the brand new template primarily based on the perfect practices I received from Newor.

I do know what you’re considering: An advert earlier than the title? Yeah, I do know. Newor insisted that individuals wouldn’t be irritated and that an early advert would set the tone for additional advertisements down the web page.

I wished to maintain issues easy for the sake of the experiment. So, I adopted swimsuit.

Also, I ought to say that the web page format isn’t as busy because it appears. We spaced out the opt-ins and advertisements so that you simply by no means noticed multiple per full web page scroll.

In addition to some small horizontal banners spaced by the content material, I additionally accepted and arrange two bigger banners within the sidebar.

Now, the advertisements have been able to go, and the research was about to start. To be sure it meant one thing, I tracked as a lot information as I might.

What was measured?

I collected information on a number of web site elements that I thought of important to my affiliate web site’s income and efficiency. To perceive how deep the influence was when advertisements confirmed up, I wanted to know…

webpage performance print out charts

  • Email Subscriber charge influence (would my conversions undergo?)
  • Speed efficiency (did the web site decelerate?)
  • Rankings (Did our pages begin dropping?)
  • Traffic (Are fewer individuals coming by)
  • Time-on-page (Are they spending much less time on the web page?)
  • Earnings from advertisements (Was all of it value it?)

Some of those elements have much less precedence than others. Speed is likely one of the highest priorities.

The Results


To decide this, we carried out a cascade of requests for every of the 37 take a look at pages utilizing Pingdom.

That allowed us to achieve out from each a San Francisco and Washington D.C. server and see how the load time modified.

Full Data for Showing Off
Full Data for Showing Off


Actually Useful Summary:

Loadtime Useful Summary table

As you’ll be able to see, there isn’t a lot proof of an issue right here. Sure, there’s a dip, but it surely’s matched by a dramatic enchancment from the opposite coast.

If I noticed a deviation of say, 3 seconds, I might be panicking. But it’s nothing near that. These outcomes are firmly within the “who cares” territory.

Next, I wanted to trace how engines like google have been responding to the adjustments.


Well, that is awkward. It seems, I forgot to inform Google that I used to be operating an experiment, and so they determined to drop the BERT algorithm replace proper in the course of it.

This occasion coloured all of my monitoring information, but it surely isn’t all unhealthy information.

BERT beloved this web site. It gave my web site such a giant hug that I can’t separate what advantages got here from the replace and what got here from our experiment.

2x increase traffic thanks BERT

In all honesty, I didn’t assume that including advertisements would have an effect on rating a lot except mixed with loads of different downward tendencies.

I noticed my first downward pattern whereas monitoring time guests spent on-page.

Results: Time on Page

The outcomes I used to be monitoring have been measured 7 and 14 days after I launched advertisements to the positioning.

Before After 7 Days After 14 Days Impact
Time on Page 3:14 2:57 2:36 -19.5%

Well, this doesn’t appear good. People are spending 20% much less time-on-page.

It’s essential to do not forget that this doesn’t all the time sign customer disgust. This could have occurred as a result of the advertisements present colourful new portals to exit the web page.

I shortly checked the bounce charge and located individuals weren’t bouncing again to SERPs basically. The bounce charge did not enhance.

That’s an excellent signal. Google doesn’t like bouncing or pogo-sticking, which signifies I didn’t serve the customer. People transferring on by transferring by is sweet for the positioning’s well being.

Overall it’s not unhealthy, however earlier than we make our last impressions of the take a look at, let’s take a fast have a look at how guests are behaving even with shorter visits.

Results: Subscriber Rate

Here’s how the subscriber charge sorted the tip of the 14-day cycle.

Before Ads After Ads Improvement
Signups 96 128 Visitors 15199 15668 Signup Rate 0.623% 0.816% 29.3%

Wait, did subscription numbers enhance after the introduction of advertisements? Yes, they did. That’s not a typo.

The experiment could have left questions so far as visitors goes, however that advertisements emboldened guests appears clear.

Ads themselves could also be a visible belief sign.

Who makes use of advertisements?

Most websites you go to. News websites just like the New York Times do – main well being data websites like WedMD do.

In truth, affiliate websites are a few of the most notably ad-free websites on the web.

Maybe including them creates slightly belief?


It takes some time for Newor’s algorithm to ramp up, however by the tip of the take a look at, earnings settled at about $28/day.

Newors Earning Chart 01

After the take a look at conclusion, the algorithm continued to optimize, ultimately settling at round $40 per day.

That’s basically $1200/month in further income with no further effort.

Newors Earning Chart 02

Bear in thoughts, when flipping websites, this $1200 month-to-month revenue achieve basically leads to a $48,000 enhance within the web site’s worth if we’re utilizing a 40x a number of.

I’ll take that any day.


Conclusion: Should You Apply Ads to Your Whole Site?

What we’ve discovered is that an affiliate web site can survive and even thrive after a transition to advertisements. Conventional knowledge tells us that advertisements ought to make web site interactions much less frequent. In this case research, I noticed the alternative.

Ad earning screenshot image

There are three conclusions you’ll be able to take away from this case research for those who’re deciding whether or not to use advertisements to your web site or not.

  1. Newor’s advertisements didn’t have an effect on web site pace
  2. Time on web page was affected negatively, however bounce wasn’t
  3. MOST IMPORTANTLY: electronic mail optins elevated, implying that affiliate clicks would possibly enhance as properly.

By the identical logic, we are able to assume that affiliate content material will observe swimsuit. However, that’s going to take much more testing, which is why I’ve already began.

If you wish to be one of many first ones to see section two, ensure you join my mailing listing.

Got Questions or Comments?

Join the dialogue here on Facebook.


Matt is the founding father of Diggity Marketing, LeadSpring, The Search Initiative, The Affiliate Lab, and the Chiang Mai website positioning Conference. He truly does website positioning too.


Check Also

Member Spotlight: Daugirdas Jankus

Launching a WordPress Product in Public: Session 14

Transcript ↓ Corey Maass and Cory Miller proceed the event of their new WordPress plugin, …