Featured Snippet Competition Banner

SERP Features Competing with Featured Snippets

February 26, 2020   |  
Posted by
Mordy Oberstein

So you have received a Featured Snippet… let the visitors stream, proper? Not so quick there! What different SERP options are displaying alongside your Featured Snippet? What different options are competing for a person’s consideration? What SERP options mostly seem with Featured Snippets? How robust is a Featured Snippet win… actually?! 

You’ve obtained questions… I’ve obtained information… 

Featured Snippet Competition Banner

Featured Snippet Strength Relative to What’s on the SERP 

In the previous, we have analyzed the power of Featured Snippet wins from a click on, machine, and market share perspective. In this research, I’ll be looking on the power of a Featured Snippet win from the attitude of the opposite options competing with it for a person’s consideration. That is, what different options does Google have a tendency to point out alongside Featured Snippets and with what frequency? 

To consider this, I utilized the key phrase database we use to gas our SERP Feature Tracker and Mobile SERP Feature Tracker, which works with roughly 125K-150K key phrases every day. With that, I pulled out the overall variety of key phrases that produced a Featured Snippet at 36 totally different information factors all through 2019 (i.e., three information factors monthly).

I then analyzed the key phrases that produced Featured Snippets at every information level to see the variety of situations the place a key phrase produced a Featured Snippet in addition to one other SERP function. For instance, on December fifteenth, 2019, our desktop dataset produced 27,890 key phrases that introduced up a Featured Snippet. Of these 27,890 key phrases, 17,660 of them additionally produced a Video Box on the identical SERP (or 66.5% of the key phrases that produced a Featured Snippet ALSO included a Video Box on the outcomes web page). I then calculated the common of this specific SERP function co-occurrence over all 36 information factors (which on this case stood at 57.1%). 

I utilized the identical course of to a number of SERP options and repeated the very same assemble for cellular. 

Here’s a fast abstract of what I discovered…

Featured Snippet and SERP Feature Co-Occurrences: Data Summary 

Below is the proportion of time a given SERP function seems on the identical outcomes web page as a Featured Snippet on each desktop and cellular: 


Knowledge Panel: 6.52% 

Local Pack: 6.55% 

Top Stories Carousel: 3.28% 

Ads: 57.39%

Video Box: 57.71% 

Related Questions: 88.13%

Video Box + Ads + Related Questions: 29.22%


Knowledge Panel: 1.17%

Local Pack: 2.56%

Top Stories Carousel: 2.05%

Ads: 54.92%

Related Questions: 63.73%

Ads + Related Questions: 48.9%

Note: You’ll discover that the cellular information doesn’t embrace Video Box information. This is as a result of now we have not constantly tracked the function on cellular till just lately (although I’ll supply preliminary information afterward). Accordingly, the final cellular metric solely reveals the proportion of Featured Snippet SERPs that include an advert and Related Questions field… not an advert, Related Questions field, and Video Box. 

This certainly is a limitation of this research. 

Check out our SERP Feature Rank Tracking information. 

What Are the Featured Snippet’s Biggest SERP Competitors? Evaluating the Traffic Potential 

Let’s dive into the info and the traits and what they are saying about how highly effective a Featured Snippet win is from a SERP function competitors perspective. Simply, what different SERP options are competing for the person’s consideration and with regularity?

Desktop Featured Snippets: Which Other SERP Features Are Competing for User Attention?

Despite our fancy for cellular, I’m going to begin with the desktop SERP. The desktop SERP, because of each display measurement and the opportunity of components to seem on the proper of the natural outcomes, is exclusive within the stage of doable SERP function competitors. 

With that, here is a visible take a look at the info: 

Featured Snippet SERP Feature Competition Desktop

As to be anticipated, Related Questions (higher referred to as People Also Ask) are paired with Featured Snippets near 90% of the time. That mentioned, now we have to think about the extent of “competition” People Also Ask (PAA) presents to a Featured Snippet qualitatively. From that perspective, I do not see the 2 preventing for a similar customers (as a rule). It’s not as if the Related Questions presents customers with questions that “compete” with the content material within the Featured Snippet. The purpose the PAA field reveals with Featured Snippets so typically is that it helps the Featured Snippet by providing ancillary questions. In different phrases, Related Questions are on the SERP as a result of they could assist customers that didn’t discover the reply inside the Featured Snippet passable if in any respect associated to their true intent. 

The actual competitors, in my estimation, comes from adverts and the Video Box. Both SERP components seem on the identical SERP as a Featured Snippet over 50% of the time. In the case of adverts, they seem above the Featured Snippet. The apparent drawback of adverts is that they’re adverts. The common person prefers one thing natural since we’re usually suspect of paid promotions to an extent. Of course, the belief issue runs concurrently with how seen an advert is. If the person would not know, or higher, skims over the truth that a outcome represents an advert then my level round belief goes proper out the window. This has occurred to an extent as over time Google has made the advert label used on the SERP much less and fewer seen with the present colorless format being the most effective instance of this. 

The Video Box presents the inverse situation in that it seems beneath the Featured Snippet, however is much extra attractive than an advert. People are visible learners. Having a chance for visible content material proper there alongside the Featured Snippet is a giant deal. Discounting situations the place the Featured Snippet is a video itself, a Video Box is a heavy distraction. Aside from the truth that the format itself is tremendously attractive to people, video media opens the door to customers who need to take heed to a solution within the background whereas they work and a bunch of different related situations. Think about it like this… would you quite learn directions about easy methods to repair your washer or just see the way it’s accomplished? Match level goes to Video Box. 

With that, the proper storm, an advert with Video Box and the Related Questions competing with a Featured Snippet, all jockeying for the person’s eye, exists almost 30% of the time! 

Rounding off the remainder of the options are Knowledge Panels, information carousels, and the Local Pack. Neither corresponds to the Featured Snippet’s look in any overwhelming method. In the case of the Local Pack and the Top Stories carousel, the person intent usually would not align to the Featured Snippet anyway. Knowledge Panels may provide the identical kind of info because the Featured Snippet, however once more, they solely seem on the identical SERP 6.5% of the time (and you would need to low cost when the Featured Snippet URL belongs to Wikipedia in such circumstances). 

Mobile Featured Snippets: What SERP Features Are They Competing With? 

The desktop and cellular SERP range enormously for quite a lot of causes… one among which is area. There merely is not any actual property to the proper of the natural outcomes on cellular as there may be on desktop. There’s much less area normally as your display on cellular is smaller than on desktop. As such, there’s a little bit of a divergence within the information when taking a look at what reveals with a Featured Snippet on cellular: 

Featured Snippet SERP Feature Competition Mobile

Right off the bat, you will discover that there’s an 82% discount within the variety of Knowledge Panels displaying with Featured Snippets, a 61% discount in Local Packs, and a 22% discount in Top Stories carousels as soon as you progress to the cellular SERP. 

Less room on the web page additionally produced 28% fewer Related Question packing containers on cellular than on desktop. The PAA field solely seems with a Featured Snippet 63.73% of the time on cellular as in comparison with desktop’s cool 88.13%.

In reality, the one “constant” have been adverts which confirmed below a two-point differential from desktop. I do not assume that stat comes as a lot of a shock because the one fixed between any Google property is income (for the document I’m not saying that in a cynical means). More than that, adverts and Related Questions each exist on near 50% of all cellular SERPs that include a Featured Snippet. 

As talked about earlier, we had not tracked the cellular Video Box till comparatively just lately. That mentioned, I did pull the info on what we have seen since we started monitoring the Video Box on cellular. Before I current that information, let me be clear that it merely hints on the stage of Featured Snippet and Video Box co-occurrences on cellular because it doesn’t replicate an exhaustive quantity of information. 

With that, here is the (restricted) information: 

Featured Snippet & Video Box Co-Occurrences (cellular): 9.55% of all SERPs

Featured Snippet, Video Box, Ads, Related Questions Co-Occurrences (cellular): 6.26% of all SERPs

This is an apparent divergence from desktop the place Video Boxes typically shared the identical SERP with Featured Snippets. This is most probably as a result of format used on every machine. Video Boxes on desktop show as a horizontal carousel. Meaning, they do not take up an enormous quantity of actual property. Mobile Video Boxes used to seem as such. However, as time went on Google started typically displaying the cellular Video Box as a sequence of vertical playing cards with the choice to see extra movies below the “Videos” tab on the SERP. Meaning, the cellular model can typically eat a considerable amount of the SERP. The preliminary information would appear to suggest that Google is just not too eager on having the quantity of area each a Featured Snippet and Video Box would occupy show on cellular too typically. This is supported by the truth that the Video Box’s desktop and cellular show ranges are minimally divergent:

Google Video Box Display Trends

Comparing Featured Snippet Competition per Device 


To higher give you an understanding of the variance between the extent of SERP function competitors your Featured Snippet wins face, here is a fast visible comparability: 

Featured Snippet Competition SERP Features per Device

Again, nothing new right here that I’ve not already outlined, it is simply useful to have a ‘graphic’ of the SERP function co-occurrences per machine. 

The one factor I’ll say is you could actually see that desktop Featured Snippets face stiffer competitors than their cellular counterparts. Consider additionally how a lot above the fold actual property Featured Snippets gobble up on cellular vs. desktop and you could possibly make the case {that a} cellular Featured Snippet has the facility to earn you extra visitors than a desktop win (all issues being equal, after all). The early information I collected on cellular Video Boxes solely accentuates this level. 

Know Thy SERP 

Looking at a Brain

It applies when rating #3 on the SERP and it applies to Featured Snippets… it pays to know what the SERP truly seems like. A Featured Snippet generally is a good thing, however the win must be certified. Part of that features analyzing the character of the key phrase. Part of meaning understanding the search quantity that the key phrase can produce. And a part of meaning understanding what different SERP options are competing for the person’s consideration. There are so many issues that may impression how customers work together with a Featured Snippet. From what else reveals above the fold to the precise quantity of above the fold area the snippet occupies, understanding what your win actually seems like may help you perceive why sure wins will not be as impactful in your web site’s visitors as others. 

When it involves qualifying a Featured Snippet win, it is all about nuance. I hope I’ve added a little bit of that with this research. 

About The Author

Mordy Oberstein

Mordy is the official liaison to the website positioning neighborhood for Wix. Despite his quite a few and far-reaching duties, Mordy nonetheless considers himself an website positioning educator at the start. That’s why you’ll discover him frequently releasing all kinds of unique website positioning analysis and evaluation!

Check Also

Member Spotlight: Daugirdas Jankus

Launching a WordPress Product in Public: Session 14

Transcript ↓ Corey Maass and Cory Miller proceed the event of their new WordPress plugin, …