How To Fail Every Marketing Class

How To Fail Every Marketing Class

It’s me. Hi. I’m mad at Ticketmaster. It’s me

That’s proper – Swiftie Maria is again once more, right here to carry you a advertising breakdown of how Ticketmaster failed Swifties, its clients, the world, and each primary advertising class ever taught.

If you’ve adopted the information not too long ago, you’ve most likely heard in regards to the upcoming Taylor Swift Eras tour. Specifically, you’ve heard about how badly Ticketmaster botched the sale. And that’s not simply offended Swifties speaking – it’s so unhealthy that the US Congress is investigating Ticketmaster for violating antitrust law.

So in case you’ve been ready for a mix roast and academic submit on Ticketmaster, then pull up a chair and seize your teacup.

Because I’ve bought a steaming pot of TEA.  

Think advertising is complicated as hell? You’re not alone.

Join over 1,000 different confused, however curious people. Download Weird Marketing’s FREE Experimental Marketing Guide.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class experimental marketing cover

How Ticketmaster’s “Verified Fan” program would have labored…in Ticketmaster’s wildest goals

First, let’s begin with what Ticketmaster thought was going to occur. 

Taylor Swift wished to ensure that tickets bought into the palms of precise Swifties and never scalpers or bots. Ticketmaster’s answer to this drawback, because it has been for different artists, is their Verified Fan program. However, as a result of Taylor Swift is such a large star and that is her first tour in years, Ticketmaster tried to stagger the entry of Swifties onto the Ticketmaster web site. The thought was that followers had been to pick out their prime three live shows. Then they might solely have the ability to store for tickets in these live performance venues’ time zones. 

Swifties submitted the knowledge to Ticketmaster, then obtained an electronic mail with their live performance choices in addition to a affirmation that they had been verified. This didn’t assure that they might take part within the Verified Fan presale occasion, nevertheless. Demand was too excessive.

But Ticketmaster knew that was coming they usually had a plan for it. On November 14, 2022, the evening earlier than the presale, Swifties can be randomly chosen from the Verified Fan pool. Then they might be notified through electronic mail, later adopted by a textual content message containing:

  • Concert date for which they had been eligible to buy
  • A procuring hyperlink
  • A singular code required for entry

It must be famous: all through the Verified Fan signup window, Taylor Swift’s crew saved including reveals because of the unprecedented demand. Additionally, Swifites who beforehand bought tickets for the canceled-for-COVID LoverFest were to receive a “boost”, as had been Swifties who obtained emails from Taylor Nation for being loyal followers. Keep this in thoughts for in a while within the article.  

How Ticketmaster imagined presale day would go

Ticketmaster instructed Swifties to make use of the hyperlink they obtained through textual content message on presale day to be able to log onto Ticketmaster. This can be accomplished half-hour earlier than 10 am, native venue time.

Using me for instance, I dwell in EST however was eligible to buy a Nashville live performance. That meant I used to be to go browsing at 9:30 central time for the ten am central time opening, though for me this was really 10:30 and 11 am japanese time respectively. 

The 30-minute ready interval was meant to permit Swifties an opportunity to ensure their cost data was updated, and that they had been logged in with out difficulty previous to the opening of the digital ready room. Ticketmaster inspired followers to maintain the web page open, saying they might robotically place followers within the digital ready room at 10 am venue time.

Once within the ready room, followers would see a bar throughout their display screen indicating what number of followers had been forward of them in line. This bar would progress like an set up bar as followers moved by the queue. Swifties understood that their distinctive code can be required to enter the queue. 

How To Fail Every Marketing Class aP3 PB3G0rNBNNsG6lhTtmJ lh9d27deW No3z2 AsIH7WlDBPGlW eWuIZMSAbnuvnk2pWk2Y PUnauyU9 qN9F9m96A 4mZHLH6dl8RHGK5CfWsmLHlxcbx34oiK5o95VnJiQKTY0uOgQZqoq5EA7gyoO Lkpr1

Once on the entrance of the road, followers can be positioned within the “ticketing room.” This display screen would present the venue format and the power to choose seats to then buy. Fans can be given half-hour within the room, however as soon as tickets had been added to their basket, they might have 8 minutes to take a look at earlier than the tickets had been launched again into the pool. 

After buying the tickets, followers would have the choice to buy parking and ticket insurance coverage after which obtain a affirmation electronic mail. 

This course of was to repeat for each time zone of the Verified Fan presale portion of the day. 

Afterward, the Capital One Pre-Sale was to go dwell a 2 pm japanese the identical day.

In abstract, gross sales would go like this:

  • 10 am EST – japanese time zone Verified Fan gross sales
  • 11 am EST – central time zone Verified Fan gross sales
  • 12 pm EST – mountain time zone Verified Fan gross sales
  • 1 pm EST – pacific time zone Verified Fan gross sales
  • 2 pm EST – Capital One Pre-Sale

This was the way it was supposed to go. But Swifties realize it didn’t prove that manner. We keep in mind what really occurred all too well.

Think advertising is complicated as hell? You’re not alone.

Join over 1,000 different confused, however curious people. Download Weird Marketing’s FREE Experimental Marketing Guide.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class experimental marketing cover

We knew you had been hassle, Ticketmaster – and the lacking codes proved it

Fact: the Verified Fan pre-sale went so badly that Swifties began calling it The Great War.

But even the day earlier than The Great War was nerve-wracking. Verified followers chosen for the presale had been imagined to obtain their emails that day.

Why was that nerve-wracking? Because the emails went out in batches, however the corresponding textual content messages had been not being despatched in the identical batch.

Around 1 pm japanese time, emails began going out. Then textual content messages with hyperlinks and codes adopted. The Swiftie Discord server I joined particularly for the Eras Tour lit up.

Some individuals obtained their emails and codes. Others had been getting solely emails, others simply codes. And some bought nothing.

I obtained my electronic mail, however no code. 

How To Fail Every Marketing Class vqYXBEsAuIM1mC6GaF9pKi6ev0737w9PXlBK8sc8Xp 1wCqEidfTx5fRf3YolkwL1QgesUzygXpqOO 7CbvLbF4xF3icXRMsHBN4w

Hours handed. I nonetheless didn’t have my code.

My good friend referred to as and mentioned she bought her electronic mail and code an hour later. So what was I imagined to do?

It was getting late and other people in Discord mentioned that for earlier live shows on Ticketmaster’s Verified Fan program, they might receive an email but no code. They couldn’t get tickets. This was not a brand new drawback.

Would I be a type of unfortunate ones? 

The delayed supply of emails and textual content message codes pointlessly tortured the Swifties

As the night progressed, I slowly morphed right into a blob of a human being. I used to be 90% nervousness, 10% human. I started questioning if the nervousness I felt, as if my life relied on receiving a single textual content, was how Zoomers felt on a regular basis. 

It wasn’t a shining second for me. 

Ticketmaster put me out of my distress seven hours later. I obtained a textual content message from a random quantity. THE random quantity. I lastly had my code. 

How To Fail Every Marketing Class c3hXq8GTdNwcmv5mVL z Ge3l7 9pdV BzC05I7d2Fgwa4IMjOZDKoBOa6Cac3IIMoBWtkzMRnu EC KkwEQS8S1ZzrRZpmpR0RAz4A ekklcNKfDYN5sZLJ6YNoKiEz iSgxzqd 9yZmJgVpsrKlYM8FIK0s9lCS8aHJP8PZp5JoFG 6IS6EwrSEKoiw

It appeared like the tip of my issues, however I ought to have recognized it wouldn’t be. The elation I used to be feeling now would quickly get replaced by extra nervousness.

I’d quickly have to succeed in into the depths of my soul for braveness and the need to press on in what would later be referred to as “The Swiftie Hunger Games.”

The Great War, or: Ticketmaster’s chaotic, drawn-out pre-sale left followers feeling burnt

I set my alarm for 8 am. Today was the day. November 15.

Even although I didn’t must be on the pc till 10:30 japanese (9:30 central), I wished to hit the Discord early and present help for the Swifties trying to acquire tickets to east coast live performance venues. I additionally wished to get a soar begin to ensure I might entry my Ticketmaster account. I all the time overlook passwords and wished to ensure my cost data was updated.

So shade me shocked after I couldn’t even get Ticketmaster’s web site to tug up.  

How To Fail Every Marketing Class 1684744869 404 giphy

Ticketmaster simply saved clocking. Then it errored out. I couldn’t even open the web page, a lot much less search for any live shows.

The solely manner I might entry the web page was by a stroke of luck. The earlier day, I had emailed myself the hyperlink I used to be texted by Ticketmaster. When I clicked that hyperlink, it introduced up Ticketmaster and by some smooth kiss from the Swiftie Gods, my Ticketmaster account robotically logged me in. To today, I don’t know the way that occurred.

The display screen mentioned I used to be within the ready room and that my display screen would robotically refresh and place me in line as soon as the suitable time got here. Sure, no drawback. But what I discovered actual fast was that I couldn’t do a single factor to mess with my web connection. The east coast Swifties had been warning others about getting booted from the system.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class fpfLWJPDEDKdbiFn0ew3o yXhOylPZKnwTou0gnm6ku0uybMdpnW6tO06Yrx5WkJilBEdHweRbZBA vCgCKfUf2B RoCw0QnOWAF7xgZwxLColKAYKOX6rLsHKulrYDMXAKBod4sj7 7RguWY4mmGvwd5C1o5sCYD1lHRI2tF6eBu2ZASTs

Slowly, the tales began getting worse as my time to enter the road was getting nearer. Thousands upon hundreds of east coast Swifties had been nonetheless ready in line. Central was about to open up. And if you realize Taylor Swift, you realize that seeing her in Nashville is a high-demand location. 

Ticketmaster dropped Swifties onto a imprecise display screen saying “2000+ people ahead of you”

Central opened up. My display screen moved me to the queue. Tummy butterflies had been a flying. I had no thought what to anticipate however I used to be going to be prepared. I had my code copied to my clipboard to enter it to get into the road…besides Ticketmaster didn’t request it. That couldn’t be good. 

How To Fail Every Marketing Class 1684744871 977 image

Well, that’s OK. I did have the increase from Taylor Nation, however I couldn’t anticipate that to place me proper in entrance of the road. After all, there have been all of the LoverFest Swifties who wanted to get precedence (as a result of they purchased tickets for a tour canceled by COVID).

But then I began seeing some discord messages about people getting seats fast who did not have either Taylor Nation boost or LoverFest. And then I noticed messages from individuals who had LoverFest and didn’t even get a code.

Then increasingly messages arrived from the east coast saying they had been getting booted out of the ticketing room. People with official codes bumped into errors. Others waited hours, solely to get despatched to the again of the road as a substitute of the ticketing room.

Something was afoot. 

Think advertising is complicated as hell? You’re not alone.

Join over 1,000 different confused, however curious people. Download Weird Marketing’s FREE Experimental Marketing Guide.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class experimental marketing cover

Pardon the interruption: Ticketmaster randomly stopped the queue for an indeterminate period of time

How To Fail Every Marketing Class ZhIdgRSaII5Lms7J5ORR7nBgS Xu9dMsPbeWrWyu9Oqkld6goGhSSOYqOY I kVYMHRABeLTxhitVMixoWlCyZa03jjj5YsW zeCSJDWhI wj1ySZDjE5t29 Pr4xniS9x8tcg2OVuaFDStrWNP SD1EBaOgHwFBuxK KfYgU8XDuovs2B0SSc2dQurqIg

Image ℅ Interview Magazine

Without warning, Ticketmaster paused the entire ticketing process. And that’s when the rumors began flying. 

Waiting in line for hours felt like demise by a thousand cuts. You would possibly name me dramatic (my husband does), however think about having to sit down in a chair for seven hours straight feeling like you might be taking part in Russian Roulette in case you dare to go to the lavatory.

Don’t let the pc go to sleep.

Don’t refresh the web page.

Avoid doing something that would probably tax the web connection, lest it make you lose your house in line. I assumed I used to be mentally and bodily ready for today. But I used to be not ready for it. I used to be too delicate.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class 0bD59yOe6JCRCEr85fF1gwOA4qK1u7gh1pONd2UCKmwaXXgZWke XqmgO1vvPlmBqC8QwRKEguXgKQUoGKze8kZCWjXrj7xj92dhPg3OWhW7kGRB1kasirJDThH CM7kRuNDvHsa8evzqAV1VKVC0mK6fT2Hv2eHmk F6dRisPrgdmDR7TYfmQrXPUeocQ
How To Fail Every Marketing Class d0KHqe8u4ReCNipUHBvO Uw1SeOuBQFJgU3uzJMEo4S5P4 VewrG2aIAwdLwiox12JEs3l2UAUzCcz6 INjsB2zDg nocSGCC8Ccp6dnOjQPrzw4kYsDgpBIjDTzvnnWf8J2hMYaqFCXQdQvEkYFF8yZyJXTtvJ NNhjyZdJX Gu5DL7FRnjhl1q4edGwA
How To Fail Every Marketing Class XqQ2H7RjdH hz0WijciBj95x0JZdQ pFkyUXQ3a1ozy1MAmVdSY61v

The Taylor Swift puns simply saved coming as all of us started to go a little bit batty. 

Ultimately, Ticketmaster screwed up so badly that you can solely get Taylor Swift tickets in case you might afford to spend hours ready on the pc

Hours glided by. I attempted getting non-internet-related work accomplished, chatted on the Discord, and cleaned my workplace for a bit. I discovered the best way to see what my place was in line by viewing the supply code of the web page.

In the tip, the Capital One Pre-Sale that was supposed to additionally occur that day was in the end pushed to the next day. The pacific coast venue gross sales had been pushed again to the afternoon.

Ticketmaster unpaused the queue with out warning after two hours. People began sending screenshots of their loading bar. The East coast had a great deal of Swifties bemoaning the truth that they had been nonetheless caught in line.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class CAr7 WC3ReX sQx 7 lVpLmUUJFJy5UH

Finally, it occurred. I used to be subsequent in line.

I used to be additionally about to vomit as a result of a number of of my new Swiftie buddies had been subsequent in line after which bought booted to the again of the road for no purpose.

I held my breath because the display screen refreshed to place me within the ticketing room….and BAM I used to be IN!

Though the sale began at 11 am japanese, I didn’t get into the ticketing room till simply earlier than 4:30 japanese. As I sat staring on the stadium seating chart attempting to make my choices, the seats had been blinking like Christmas lights. The similar tickets had been showing and disappearing time and again.

The 7-minute ticket maintain was not working the way in which it was imagined to. It was insanity.

I grabbed my tickets, paid, after which went again to ship screenshots to the Discord. In a matter of quarter-hour, I watched the stadium promote out. 

Note: there have been nonetheless individuals ready in line for hours after me, solely to get into the ticketing room and discover it offered out. There had been nonetheless individuals on the east coast who had not gotten into the ticketing room by the point I bought my tickets. 

Like I mentioned – insanity. 

I Think There’s Been a Glitch: Ticketmaster offered out all the final sale tickets earlier than it was imagined to

As unhealthy as my expertise was, I used to be pretty fortunate. I’d be remiss if I didn’t cowl what occurred within the subsequent 24 hours.

The subsequent two time zones opened up a lot later than initially promised. While it was nonetheless an insane mad sprint to get tickets, the pacific time zone venues had a greater procuring expertise because the servers had been not fully overloaded. 

The subsequent day was the Capital One Pre-Sale occasion. I attended this as I wished to nonetheless attempt to rating ground seats. Already, the method was considerably higher, albeit I nonetheless needed to wait quite a bit. The line was shorter, however the ticket buy web page resembled Christmas lights once more. Available seats can be there one second, then gone the subsequent. And that pre-sale offered out even quicker. I watched it occur. 

Here’s the catch. After the Capital One Pre-Sale, Ticketmaster canceled the final sale. They had been out of tickets. The complete tour offered out. 

Ticketmaster didn’t put aside tickets for the final sale, screwing over everybody who wasn’t a part of Taylor Nation, the LoverFest tour, a Verified Fan, or the Capital One Pre-Sale

Swifties had been SHOOK.

This was not imagined to occur.

Only a sure proportion of the tickets had been to be offered in the course of the two presale occasions mixed. An entire different set of tickets was imagined to be accessible for basic sale that Friday. So how might they probably be offered out? 

There must have been a glitch. 

Or some critical shady enterprise. 

Tickets had been already popping up on resale web sites, with one ticket in Houston going for $22,000. Nosebleed seats for $500 had been thought-about a cut price. Scammers got here out of the woodwork.

If you had been fortunate sufficient to attain tickets, you had been suggested to vary your Ticketmaster password. Hackers focused accounts with Taylor Swift tickets.

Up thus far, neither Taylor Nation nor Taylor Swift herself had made a press release. They simply saved releasing re-mixes of Anti-Hero, the irony not misplaced on any of us Swifties. 

Just after midday japanese on November 18, Taylor Swift made her assertion. It was quick, it was clear. She drew on the cat-eye sharp enough to kill a monopoly. She was dressing for revenge.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class c6RbWDFfX7kr lmaxRxVvA DhzWZKPe3SVPEtRVEXVVSCLdneIFjf7z n7hyfG7O3GkcdxZyTTQywLk6TCGurNWfrevxYwo1AI 93nT7C3t9YtEhkkAA9FMnih SJvqp1WK9a

Ticketmaster is a de facto monopoly. That’s the one purpose they will get away with this.

Music followers have handled crummy ticketing experiences for years. It was virtually a proper of passage to attend a high-demand live performance. Ariana Grande, Olivia Rodrigo, and Harry Styles additionally had traditionally intense ticketing experiences. But even rock stars for the older crowds have been impacted too, such because the latest Bruce Springsteen debacle.

Ticketmaster has been an issue for a very long time. Pearl Jam even fought them in court all the way back in 1995.

So why now? Why are Ticketmaster and LiveNation in sizzling water now?


Taylor Swift has grabbed the highlight for smashing records and fighting the good fight towards big conglomerates.

Swift has constructed herself a fame for combating for what is nice and proper, and not is she letting herself be pushed round. And if she will get weary, she has hundreds of thousands of Swifties there to again her up.

So it has taken an artist like Taylor Swift, who had a big sufficient and devoted sufficient fan base spanning a number of generations – nearly all of whom are extremely tech savvy – to get the eye of the Tennessee Attorney General, North Carolina Attorney General, the Justice Department, and Congress itself to lastly look into the LiveNation and Ticketmaster monopoly. 

How To Fail Every Marketing Class Y36U4GMDhp4qBEcTph ZcRyH8ggN09KO9 sIFU 81BzVqYzzwMJ1rFddjhHBNDNTsbgI35CQBTa12nwdbLnikpX FG5Xx1 78wuSKVZs2i7V TuZJP5pQIMsOnf4041JZqlM vXHguojWtgepOtZP7LlSe7vkUH EMwYKGQguoqMiBNSaQ3WUz92 2NLSg
Justice Dept. Is Said to Investigate Ticketmaster’s Parent Company, New York Times

Ticketmaster has a lot energy {that a} famous person who took her music again from her personal report label didn’t have any viable various for ticketing

Based on Swift’s assertion, it was clear that she was compelled into working with LiveNation/Ticketmaster as a result of an absence of competitors within the trade. LiveNation controls entry to most main music venues within the United States. Want entry to a LiveNation venue? You must undergo Ticketmaster. No choice.

If it walks like a monopoly and talks like a monopoly, then it’s most likely a monopoly.

In case you had been questioning, the final time Congress bought concerned in one thing like this was when Facebook was dealing with antitrust violations. 

Up thus far, Ticketmaster has been rising and forming vital relationships with live performance venues all through the United States. The 2010 acquisition by LiveNation solely additional improved that development. Users favored the Ticketmaster interface, and the identify was trusted again within the day.

But extra ticketing experiences are starting to resemble the Eras Tour. Their enterprise practices are seeing elevated scrutiny. Now a once-in-a-generation music star like Taylor Swift says that she was compelled into enterprise with Ticketmaster as a result of there have been no different accessible choices within the market providing the identical service.

At the time I’m penning this, Congress has given the CEO of LiveNation till December 15 to schedule a briefing with Congress to debate the method used for the Eras Tour ticketing expertise. 

Time will inform what occurs to LiveNation and Ticketmaster. Will they keep BFFs? Will they be torn aside?

We don’t know but. All we all know is that Taylor Swift and her team proceed on with their vigilante shit.

But what we do know is that Ticketmaster’s monopolstic management over dwell music ticketing has allowed them to get away with failing in any respect the advertising fundamentals.

Think advertising is complicated as hell? You’re not alone.

Join over 1,000 different confused, however curious people. Download Weird Marketing’s FREE Experimental Marketing Guide.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class experimental marketing cover

Ticketmaster vs. the 4 P’s of Marketing

One of the primary belongings you’ll study in advertising class: the 4 P’s of selling. Ticketmaster and LiveNation, a very long time in the past, understood these classes. But in some unspecified time in the future, they forgot them. So let’s have a look at how their monopoly standing makes them exempt from essentially the most primary advertising guidelines.


In advertising, promotion is each methodology of communication that you just use to tell individuals a couple of services or products.

Why the 4 P’s of Marketing Remain So Important

Ticketmaster didn’t must do a lot to advertise the Taylor Swift occasion. Her fan base is virtually one large omniscient being. For me, the way in which that I knew in regards to the Eras Tour was by the social media profiles of Taylor Swift, Taylor Nation, and their mailing checklist. The communication was detailed and frequent, and it laid out the method and made very clear what the vital dates to know had been in case you wished to get tickets to the tour. 

As for the Capital One Pre-Sale occasion, benefit from the beneath promotional industrial that Ticketmaster, Capital One, and Taylor Swift put collectively. It’s actually one among my favourite issues, regardless of the bitter style of how the occasions really went down. 

Promotion is about message technique and frequency, in addition to adverts and PR. But execution is a vital a part of promotion. Ticketmaster botched that.

You wanted an electronic mail and textual content message code to purchase a ticket. But textual content message codes and emails didn’t exit on the similar time. Some individuals didn’t get them in any respect. And for individuals who did, the codes typically didn’t work.

Some individuals logged on, waited for hours, after which bought kicked out of the ticketing room and put again in line. It was utter chaos.

Then the final sale was canceled as a result of Ticketmaster unintentionally promoting out tickets too early. Figure that one out.

Basically, Ticketmaster invalidated all prior communication with their abysmal execution of the sale.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class giphy 1


Place sometimes refers to how simply clients can entry an organization and the way handy it’s to purchase from them. Ticketmaster is a digital ticketing system, so their “place” is their web site and digital ready room. It’s additionally the place they screwed up the worst. 

Through the Verified Fan program, Ticketmaster hoped to gauge the quantity of internet visitors they might be experiencing on November 15. But their servers couldn’t deal with the visitors surge, they usually needed to pause the pre-sale course of.

In reality, they saved sending out emails stating the historic demand. Yet, their servers had been nonetheless lower than snuff, leading to the complete pre-sale course of being paused for an undetermined period of time. 

During the Taylor Swift sale, clients merely couldn’t reliably entry Ticketmaster. Codes by no means arrived or didn’t work. Customers had been randomly booted from the ticketing room as a result of server errors, having to begin once more in the back of the road.

Now I’m grounded sufficient to acknowledge that not all the errors had been Ticketmaster’s fault. I’m positive among the codes or cost points had been person errors. But I used to be in direct communication with fellow Swifties who had been utilizing the codes issued to them by Ticketmaster, for the proper date and venue, they usually had been getting kicked out. Other customers that I spoke with had been being booted to the again of the road once they had been subsequent to be allowed into the ticketing system.

Simply put: Ticketmaster didn’t put together their place for an enormous sale.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class giphy 2

But what in regards to the weblog submit Ticketmaster launched?

The one defending their preparation?” 

Yes. Let’s discuss that.

Ticketmaster posted two weblog posts. The first was deleted inside hours of its posting as a result of backlash. In the second, Ticketmaster states that solely 40% of customers who signal as much as be Verified will really store the tour.

Be that as it might, there are all the time exceptions to the rule. 

Ticketmaster didn’t assume this by. Swifties are notoriously devoted. Taylor Swift has not toured in 4 years because of the pandemic. The demand for tickets was huge.

With a lot uncertainty round demand, Ticketmaster ought to have ready their servers for at least 60% of the Verified Fan accounts. 

Which, talking of the Verified Fan accounts – keep in mind that Verified Fans didn’t must enter their codes till after reaching the ticketing room. The codes had been imagined to be the gatekeepers. So why let the programs get flooded with hundreds of thousands of followers, solely to later boot them out? Ticketmaster had the correct instruments, they only forgot to make use of them. 

And lastly, with reference to Place, Ticketmaster ought to have scheduled gross sales farther aside. Leaving only one hour between every time zone clearly was not sufficient time. Consider that there have been hundreds of followers within the japanese time zone ready in line when the central time zone venues opened up. 

So what can we take away from this? Standard practices and guidelines of thumb are vital when making ready your house. But keep in mind that each shopper and scenario is completely different. Sometimes, you must work outdoors of the requirements to deal with obstacles beforehand.


This ought to have been easy. Ticketmaster had the product. They had all of the tickets.

Taylor Swift tickets are mainly gold. Perfect product-market match. Practically not possible to screw up.

But they unintentionally offered all of the tickets in the course of the Verified Fan and Capital One Pre-Sale occasions. So they didn’t have any put aside for the final sale.

The drawback right here is so apparent that I received’t elaborate.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class giphy 3


Price is one other a part of advertising. Too excessive and other people received’t purchase, too low and also you received’t make a revenue. The value itself units expectations for the standard of the product.

But it’s not nearly the price of the products/companies themselves. You must think about charges and ancillary related prices.

Concerts should value their tickets primarily based on paying the artist, different performers, choreographers, wardrobe/make-up, sound/lighting, safety, and so forth. Then there are all the prices the venue will tackle, similar to safety, concessions, electrical energy, and extra employees. So much goes into pricing.

But Ticketmaster managed to screw this up too with their Highway Robbery system, higher often called Dynamic Pricing and Platinum Tickets. Fortunately for Swifties, Taylor Swift didn’t permit both of those practices to be put into place, though there have been a plethora of high-priced VIP packages with little actual worth. 

What’s Dynamic Pricing? Basically, a rip-off. Dynamic pricing permits seat costs to vary primarily based on the quantity of demand on the time. In Bruce Springsteen’s case, ground seats periodically surged to a number of thousand {dollars} every. And individuals purchased them.

What, pray inform, then, are Platinum Tickets? They say “Optimal Platinum” or “Platinum VIP.” It’s only a fancy label for the next ticket value. The seats are the identical, there isn’t a particular perk, only a larger price ticket. In a manner, they’re sucker’s model of self-importance pricing. (Seriously.)

Again, we thank our Queen Taylor Swift for being a Swiftie herself and never permitting Ticketmaster to make use of Dynamic Pricing or Platinum Tickets. She singlehandedly stopped Ticketmaster from failing fully on this P.

(And but their basic sale screw-up nonetheless put tickets within the palms of scalpers. Now nosebleeds are going for $500. So did they actually cross?)

Think advertising is complicated as hell? You’re not alone.

Join over 1,000 different confused, however curious people. Download Weird Marketing’s FREE Experimental Marketing Guide.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class experimental marketing cover

Ticketmaster vs. the 4 C’s of Marketing

Let’s take one other tremendous primary advertising mannequin: the 4 C’s of Marketing. Surprise: Ticketmaster fully flunked right here too.


So a lot of selling revolves round retaining your buyer base comfortable. You have to think about their desires and wishes, and how one can fulfill them. That will allow you to construct a loyal buyer base.

Or you possibly can simply overlook all that, construct a monopoly, and the purchasers received’t have an choice.

Ticketmaster had two clients when it got here to the Eras Tour: Swifties and Taylor Swift herself. Ticketmaster let each down.

As said earlier on this submit, Taylor Swift’s crew was compelled into partnering with Ticketmaster because of the stadium contracts in place. Kind of onerous to have a stadium tour in case you can’t ebook the stadiums as a result of non-compete contracts with a ticketing workplace. 

Now let’s have a look at the Swifties. They too are clients as they’re those buying the ticket and serving to Ticketmaster make a tidy revenue. And regardless of Ticketmaster performing shocked as to the historic numbers of followers that turned out to the pre-sales, they said themselves that there have been 3.5 million Verified Fan signups. That’s plenty of clients. 

So how did Ticketmaster fail these clients? Two methods.

First, their horrendous buyer expertise failed to think about ticket patrons’ wants.

Second, they threw their different buyer underneath the bus – Taylor Swift herself. The evening of the Capital One Pre-Sale, a boss for LiveNation was interviewed on CNBC.

According to him, it’s Swift’s fault for being “too famous” and having not toured in 4 years (three of which occurred throughout a once-in-a-century world pandemic). And in response to the since-deleted weblog submit by Ticketmaster, the pre-sale occasions had been big successes and there was no want for individuals to be all labored up. 

How To Fail Every Marketing Class giphy 4

They solely bought away with this as a result of they’re a monopoly.

Taylor Swift had her palms tied, watching Ticketmaster play the fiddle whereas the Swifties burned. 


Cost is similar to value within the 4 P’s, however it additionally takes under consideration non-monetary bills. Time can be thought-about a value. And time is what Ticketmaster robbed its clients of on November 15.

As I’ve already defined in nice element how Ticketmaster stole two days’ price of my time (and oh a lot extra in my psychological well being), let’s as a substitute have a look at how this isn’t the primary time Ticketmaster has accomplished this.

Ever heard of Olivia Rodrigo? Or maybe the music Drivers License? She is a seven-time Grammy award nominee who runs in the identical musical circles as Taylor Swift, Ariana Grande, Harry Styles, Shawn Mendez, Halsey, and even Justin Beiber. When she held her pre-sale ticketing occasion with Ticketmaster, an analogous destiny occurred to her followers. Almost exactly. Fans waited for hours solely to be kicked out of the queue with codes not working. 

The ticket price is excessive. The intangible price of losing a whole day attempting to get tickets one way or the other manages to be larger.

Now Ticketmaster will get a style of their very own drugs, paying each the tangible and intangible prices of going to courtroom.


Generally talking, Ticketmaster is constructed upon comfort. Fans don’t have to attend outdoors a ticketing workplace. That’s good.

Enthusiasts can merely whip out their telephones or open a brand new tab on their pc and buy tickets on-line. But when it got here to the Eras tour, Ticketmaster managed to make one thing worse than really going someplace to purchase a ticket.

I don’t learn about you, however having to sit down at a pc for 7 hours with out leaving isn’t handy. Sure, desk jobs contain sitting at a pc all day, however at the least staff can stand up for water, use the restroom, and even go for a stroll on their lunch break.

Not within the Swiftie Hunger Games.

I used to be caught in a nerve-wracking hellscape for hours. The procuring hyperlinks went out by textual content, however Ticketmaster all however required followers to buy tickets on a pc (which not everybody has). Then there was the aforementioned “temporary pause” that lasted two hours, the “2,000+ People Ahead of You” display screen which hid the truth that typically 30,000 individuals can be forward of you in line.

So did Ticketmaster make buying tickets handy? Hell no. 


Initially, Ticketmaster really did a very good job right here. They clearly outlined the steps of the best way to develop into a Verified Fan, and even set the expectations that not each Verified Fan would obtain a code. It was a harsh reality, however provide and demand is an actual factor and Ticketmaster did a very good job expressing that piece. 

What they then tanked was every little thing thereafter. 

Ticketmaster staff who had been responding to direct messages on Twitter had been giving conflicting data. Some statements mentioned that the final sale was not canceled, simply postponed. Others mentioned that there have been no tickets. Others mentioned that there have been 800,000 tickets. 

Then there have been conflicting messages relating to the stadium staff. One lady mentioned a stadium worker tried promoting tickets at scalper costs whereas the ticketing course of was on maintain. Whereas others have been advised that the stadiums do not know what number of tickets there are and solely know what the general public is aware of. 

The purpose for the pause continues to be up for debate. Was it as a result of Ticketmaster not really inputting all of the codes into the system? Was it as a result of the servers had been overloaded? Both? 

Did scalpers get in, like they did for Olivia Rodrigo’s Sour live performance? 

And then in fact there may be the beforehand linked Ticketmaster preliminary weblog submit explaining the Eras Tour catastrophe, which needed to be shortly taken down and reworked because of the backlash it obtained. If you haven’t checked out the hyperlink, the submit was all however bragging about how historic the ticketing occasion was, ignoring the truth that it failed at speaking with its clients in a significant manner.

Not precisely one of the best ways to speak with one’s clients, if I do say so myself. 

Dear Reader

I hope that you’ve got loved studying this text as a lot as I had writing it. I’ve by no means been part of a group which may really create change, so it’s thrilling and attention-grabbing to me to see how Swifties is perhaps what lastly will get lawmakers to look into Ticketmaster & LiveNation. Will or not it’s the subsequent Facebook Trials? Only time will inform. 

But what we will study from this postmortem of the Eras Tour sale is what NOT to do by way of advertising fundamentals. 

And if any Ticketmaster or Live Nation Board Member is studying this – be at liberty to succeed in out. I’d be comfortable to offer you a personal lesson in your Marketing’s Ps and Cs. 

Think advertising is complicated as hell? You’re not alone.

Join over 1,000 different confused, however curious people. Download Weird Marketing’s FREE Experimental Marketing Guide.

How To Fail Every Marketing Class experimental marketing cover

Check Also

A Columbia University Professor Urges Art Students to “Embrace the Machines” In Digital Storytelling—Here’s How His Lessons Are Relevant to Business Owners Looking to Creatively Collaborate with AI

A Columbia University Professor Urges Art Students to “Embrace the Machines” In Digital Storytelling—Here’s How His Lessons Are Relevant to Business Owners Looking to Creatively Collaborate with AI

A latest New York Times article detailed a professor who’s one thing of an anomaly …